Termination without notice in the event of noise pollution — protect your rights as a tenant and landlord!

1. What is noise pollution in tenancy law?

Noise pollution is an evergreen in tenancy law — disputes over loud neighbors, disturbances of peace at night or rumbling noises are part of everyday life in German apartment buildings. But when does noise become legally relevant and in which cases is there actually a risk of termination of the rental agreement without notice?

In principle, it should be noted that not every form of noise immediately justifies legal action. In a residential building, mutual consideration must be given to each other to a certain extent. Especially outside legal rest periods, the threshold for a breach of contract is usually higher than during a night's rest (usually 10 pm to 6 am).

2. Legal framework: Termination without notice after SECTION 543 BGB

The central legal basis is Section 543 (1) BGB — termination without notice for good cause. Termination of the rental agreement without compliance with the notice period is therefore only permitted if the terminator can no longer be expected to continue the contractual relationship, taking into account all circumstances and interests.

Termination without notice due to noise pollution requires:

‍

• Significant breach of contract by the tenant
• The frequency and intensity of the noise must unreasonably affect the use of the apartment of the other tenants
• Prior warning usually required (exception: particularly serious cases)

An important reason exists in particular if the disturbances permanently destroy peaceful coexistence and the tenant shows no will to improve even after a warning. All details on the legal background can be found in SECTION 543 BGB.

‍

‍

‍

‍

3. Typical types of noise pollution — and their legal assessment

Not all noise is the same — depending on the type, duration and cause, the courts have developed certain standards.

Typical examples of noise pollution:

‍

• Loud music or parties, especially during rest periods — can be warned regularly, reason for termination if repeated
• Raging children — socially accepted, legally tolerated, unless there are exceptional situations of constant disturbance of peace
• Repeated loud household appliances after 22:00 — can be a warning
• Loud quarrels, screaming, rumbling — especially at night: serious breach of duty
• Animal noise, such as dog barking — evaluation by duration and intensity

‍

4. The judgment of AG Münster 2024 — consequences for practice

The current verdict of the Münster District Court (Az. 8 C 123/23, Feb. 2024) sets an important tone. The focus was on a family of eight tenants who repeatedly stood out in the apartment building due to continuous screams of children, late evening noise and loud household appliances. The neighbors complained several times, and several warnings were unsuccessful.

The court found:

“The continued noise pollution represents a significant breach of rental contract obligations. In particular, the proven intensity and frequency, paired with the lack of insight on the part of tenants even after repeated express warning, constitutes an important reason within the meaning of Section 543 (1) BGB. The termination without notice is therefore justified. ”

— Münster District Court, judgment of 21.02.2024, file no. 8 C 123/23

Practical significance:
Courts require clear, documented evidence. Only if warnings, noise reports, witness statements and any sound recordings or further evidence can be presented will an immediate termination be valid. Tenants and landlords should therefore always document and seek legal advice at an early stage in case of uncertainty.

‍

5. Action steps in case of noise pollution: What do tenants or landlords do?

For tenants:

Take the complaint seriously: Anyone who receives a warning should respond immediately — do not ignore the letter under any circumstances!

Seek a conversation: Clarify misunderstandings with the landlord or stop the complained behavior.

Documentation: Keep a record yourself if you feel wrongly accused and prepare a reply.

Legal advice: Have the warning or even a dismissal reviewed by a lawyer and advise you on further steps.

For landlords:

Preservation of evidence: Have complaints from neighbors documented in writing, keep records yourself and, if necessary, obtain witness statements.

Warnings: Before termination, an effective warning with a specific description is usually required.

Termination and judicial enforcement: If there is no improvement, review the termination without notice and prepare it carefully. In the event of an escalation, an eviction action may be required.

Services provided by Depenbrock Law Firm:

‍
As an experienced lawyer in tenancy law, I support both tenants and landlords nationwide with:

‍

• initial assessment
• Extrajudicial and judicial representation
• Review and preparation of warnings and terminations

‍
Early legal advice is invaluable, especially when it comes to noise pollution — so get in touch with lawyer Depenbrock from Telgte in good time!

‍

6. FAQ: The most important questions and answers

‍

‍

7. Conclusion

Noise pollution is no small matter — it can certainly justify the immediate termination of a rental agreement in the event of repetition. However, as the landmark judgment of AG Münster shows, the case law requires detailed documentation and usually a prior warning.

The following applies to tenants and landlords alike: In conflict situations, keep calm, document carefully and seek legal advice at an early stage. This is the only way you can effectively secure your rights and avoid costly mistakes.

Act prudently! Your interests in tenancy law are in experienced hands at Depenbrock law firm. Contact us for tailored advice and dedicated representation — whether out of court or in court.

Please note: The content of our website is for informational purposes only and does not replace qualified legal advice that addresses the specific circumstances of your individual case. The legal situation can always change as a result of new court rulings or legal changes. If you would like a binding legal opinion or personal advice, we will be happy to help you. Get in touch with us anytime.

Cover photo: Karl Hedin

‍